Saturday, November 14, 2026

Two States, Two PBs, and One Epic Fishing Trip

Locations: Old Hickory and J Percy Priest in Tennessee and Cave Run Lake in Kentucky

Fishing Time: Old Hickory – November 12, Cave Run Lake – November 13, and J Percy Priest – November 14

Weather: First two days was cloudy, breezy, and cold.  Last day was clear skies, light breeze, and warmer

Moon Phase: 25% Waxing Moon

Water Temp: 57-63 degrees

Best Baits: Live gizzard shad, bull dawg, and 6th sense flutter spoon

Who Went: Bobber John, Rick Everson, Dunc

Rick and I had one simple goal: head back east, spend a few days with Bobber John, and fish some new water. What followed turned into one of the most memorable fishing adventures I've ever had catching two new personal best fish.

Our first stop was Old Hickory Reservoir outside Nashville, where Bobber has striped bass fishing completely figured out. Before we could chase stripers, however, we needed bait. That meant throwing the cast net, which was probably Rick's favorite part of the entire trip. He could have spent all day launching that net. Fortunately, it didn't take long before we had enough bait to rig six live bait rods and start striper fishing.






With the bait rods soaking, we started casting artificial lures toward the shoreline. My confidence was high as I launched a $50 glide bait into the water. Five casts later, it was permanently attached to the bottom and gone. No problem, I switched to a $20 spoon. Three casts later, the spoon was gone. In less than fifteen minutes I'd donated $70 worth of tackle to Tennessee. Thankfully, the live bait saved the day before I could lose more money.

I was sitting near the bow watching the live scope when the rod beside me suddenly doubled over and line began screaming from the reel. I grabbed it and the fight was on. The fish made several powerful runs before finally letting Bobber put a net on it. A few moments later, I was holding a 19-pound striped bass, my personal best and an absolute giant.

The Battle

The action wasn't over. Another rod shortly took off, although that fish managed to escape before getting solidly hooked. We ended up boating one more small striper that Bobber handled himself. It was a great start to the trip and exactly what we had hoped for from Old Hickory.

That evening we checked out Bobbers new house in Bowling Green, Kentucky then stopped by a Buc-ee's for a fuel up and brisket sandwich, before settling in for a four-hour drive north to our next destination, Cave Run Lake, known as the "Musky Capital of the South."

Nestled along the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains in Kentucky, Cave Run felt completely different from the waters I fish back home. Limestone bluffs dropped into the lake, and the shoreline was lined with towering oaks and maples trying to hang on to their last fall colors.

Before launching, we stopped at a local bait shop to gather some local knowledge. We stocked up on fresh 9-12 inch suckers, and purchased several ridiculous musky lures that looked more suited for catching sea monsters than freshwater fish. The weather was cool and windy, with dark clouds threatening rain all day but never delivering.

Bobber parked the boat onto a flat where local guides reported musky activity. We set up between a weed line and a drop-off, engaged Spot Lock on the trolling motor, and started fishing in about 15-feet of water. Live baits went overboard while we began firing giant lures in every direction.

After about ten casts, I quickly realized my rod setup wasn't built to throw the gigantic 15-inch tube bait we'd purchased. Digging through Bobber's tackle box, I found a smaller Bull Dawg and began fan-casting around the boat.

Then things got silly.  Within fifteen minutes, a live sucker produced the first musky of the day. Soon after, another sucker got crushed. Not long after, my Bull Dawg suddenly felt heavy and I connected with my first musky of the day. Three muskies in the boat within the first hour. For a species famously called "the fish of ten thousand casts," it felt like we had somehow skipped the hard part.

Rick on a Musky

Dunc's First Musky

Bobber Needs a Net

The action never slowed. We continued catching fish throughout the morning. At one point I connected on a 6th Sense flutter spoon, proving the muskies were willing to eat just about anything we threw at them. By day's end, we had landed seven muskies and lost another that bit a hole through our net and slipped free.  We didn’t even care. We had eight musky encounters at the boat in a single day! Bobber didn’t have a measuring tape, but every fish appeared to be between 35 and 42 inches long. A local guide later told us that the most muskies he'd ever landed in a single day on Cave Run Lake was seven. What an incredible day!

When the chaos finally ended we left and headed back toward Nashville and the final day of fishing brought us back to reality. A cold front had moved through overnight, leaving behind one of those brutal bluebird days fishermen love to hate. We spent half the day chasing striped bass at Old Hickory without success. Refusing to quit, we made a last-minute run to J. Percy Priest Reservoir in search of hybrid bass. The move to Percy produced a few small fish, but nothing exciting. Before long, daylight faded, rods were packed away, and it was time to head for the airport.

Looking back, the numbers only tell part of the story. I landed my personal-best striped bass at 19 pounds and caught four muskies despite never having caught one before this trip. We explored new water, drove across Kentucky, saw Bobber's new place in Bowling Green, cast-netted our own live bait, watched college football in Nashville, and spent a few unforgettable days doing what we love most. The fishing was incredible, but the memories made between catches are what I'll remember most. Some trips are successful because of the fish. Others are memorable because of the people. This one had both, and it'll undoubtedly go down for the Trio as one for the history books.